Friday, May 1, 2015

2015 NFL Draft Grades

Round 1:

2015 Draft in Review: Detroit Lions (Round 1: Laken Tomlinson, G, Duke: Grade: A, Tomlinson was our top true guard heading into the draft. He excels as a run blocker and consistently wins in one-on-one situations at the line of scrimmage. He had the second-highest run block grade against Power 5 opponents, and as a pass blocker, he was the top guard in the draft class with a 99.4 Pass Blocking Efficiency, allowing no sacks, no hits, and just four hurries. To top it off, the Lions picked up two fifth-round picks and Manny Ramirez in a trade to move back five spots, and still were able to draft the player they were targeting. Depth Chart Fit: Tomlinson should slide in as the starter at left guard Day 1, while Ramirez and Travis Swanson compete for the starting center job.) (5-6-15):   https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/05/01/2015-draft-in-review-detroit-lions/

Syracuse.com's grades (Lions get an A:   The Lions moved back in the draft, collected picks and grabbed one of the best offensive guards in the draft. They got better on Thursday night.):  http://www.syracuse.com/buffalo-bills/index.ssf/2015/04/2015_nfl_draft_grades_assessing_jameis_winston_and_the_rest_of_the_first-round_p.html

Day 1 quick-snap grades for all 32 teams (Lions get an A-: The skinny: In a span of about 30 minutes, the Lions upgraded their interior offensive line quite a bit and managed to get more picks in the draft during the process. Matthew Staffordis no doubt quite happy at this news and while some see Tomlinson a reach at the tail end of the first round, he's a super safe pick that helps the team.):   http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000489142/article/2015-nfl-draft-day-1-quicksnap-grades-for-nfc-teams

SI '15 NFL draft round 1: Grades for each team (Lions get an A-):   http://www.si.com/nfl/2015/04/30/detroit-lions-select-laken-tomlinson-2015-nfl-draft 

NBCChicago grades the NFC North (The Lions got the highest grade.  Detroit Lions: B+: The Lions had the best night out of anyone in the NFC North as they not only were able to bolster their offensive line with Manny Ramirez and Laken Tomlinson, but they also grabbed a couple more draft picks in the process as they made a swap with the Denver Broncos to move down five spots in the first round. Sure, the Lions have some holes that they still need to fill (defensive tackle immediately springs to mind), but giving Matthew Stafford more time in the pocket was worth the sacrifice. Ramirez is an excellent player that is sure to fit in well on that line, and Tomlinson is one of the smartest and most adaptable linemen in this draft class. The Lions could’ve potentially gone for Malcolm Brown instead in the draft, but Tomlinson also makes sense, so we won’t ding them for that choice.):  http://www.nbcchicago.com/blogs/grizzly-detail/NFL-Draft-Grading-the-NFC-North-After-Day-One--302147851.html

CBS Grades - 2015 NFL Draft: Lions get B+ for picking Laken Tomlinson No. 28:   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-football/25169644/nfl-draft-lions-get-b-for-picking-laken-tomlinson-no-28

Walterfootball Draft Grades (Lions get a B+ for the Laken Tomlinson pick: This is a slight reach - I thought the right area for Laken Tomlinson was the top half of the second round - but that's mitigated by the fact that the Lions moved down five spots and picked up some commodities in the process. That moves this grade from a "B" to a B+. I like Tomlinson as a prospect, as he projects as a solid guard. He fills a big need for the Lions, who struggled mightily to protect Matthew Stafford last year. Stafford has to love this pick.):   http://walterfootball.com/nfldraftgrades1.php

NJ.com's Grades (Lions get a B+:  The Lions strengthen at guard by re-acquiring Manny Ramirez in a deal with the Broncos before grabbing Tomlinson.):  http://www.nj.com/giants/index.ssf/2015/04/nfl_draft_2015_live_first-round_grades_pick-by-pic.html

Josh Katzenstein grades every first-round pick (The Lions get a B: Detroit (from Denver): Laken Tomlinson, G, Duke. The Lions haven’t taken an interior offensive lineman in the first round since Jeff Hartings in 1996, and it’s rare for a guard to go in Round 1. But left guard was the biggest question mark the Lions had, and they filled it with Tomlinson and Manny Ramirez while receiving two picks from the Broncos.):  http://www.detroitnews.com/picture-gallery/sports/nfl/lions/2015/04/30/josh-katzenstein-grades-every-first-round-pick/26683047/

Washington Post Grades (The Lions fortified the interior of their offensive line by getting G Manny Ramirez in a trade to move down five spots, then using the 28th choice on G Laken Tomlinson. There is room to question whether Detroit should have taken DT Malcom Brown, especially after losing Ndamukong Suh and Nick Fairley in free agency. Brown ended up going 32nd to New England. Grade: B):  http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/sports/wp/2015/05/01/2015-nfl-draft-grades-patriots-seahawks-jets-ace-round-1/

Grades:

A: 2
A-:   2
B+:  4
B:  2

Round 2:

Walter football Draft Grades ( 54. Ameer Abdullah, RB, Nebraska: A Grade - Reggie Bush had a nice start to his Detroit career, but he flamed out, making countless mistakes toward the end of his tenure there. The Lions had to find a replacement for Bush, and they managed to do so with Ameer Abdullah, a game-breaking running back who can go the distance every time he touches the ball. Abdullah could develop into a three-down back if he learns how to block better. Even still, he'll make the Lions' offense so much more explosive.) :   http://walterfootball.com/offseason2015det.php

2015 Draft in Review: Detroit Lions (Round 2: Ameer Abdullah, RB, Nebraska: Grade: B+, Abdullah was one of my favorite players to watch in the draft. He plays much bigger than his size would suggest, and can make cuts that few, if any, other players in this draft can make. Abdullah had the second-highest rush grade and highest receiving grade in the RB draft class. He will need to improve in pass protection to be an every down player, but that’s really the only weakness in his game. Depth Chart Fit: Will split time with Joique Bell, but should see significant playing time, especially on early downs.) (5-6-15):   https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/05/01/2015-draft-in-review-detroit-lions/

SI's Grades - Detroit Lions Select Ameer Abdullah No. 54 In 2015 Nfl Draft (Lions get a B+):   http://www.si.com/nfl/2015/05/01/detroit-lions-select-ameer-abdullah-2015-nfl-draft

CBS Grades (Lions get a C+):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-football/25168934/nfl-draft-lions-get-c-for-picking-ameer-abdullah-at-no-54

Grades:

A: 1
B+: 2
C+: 1

Round 3:

Walter football Draft Grades (80. Alex Carter, CB, Stanford: A- Grade - Here's the Alex Carter pick. I thought Carter would go to the Steelers or Packers at the end of the second round, given that he fit their scheme so well. The Lions have to be thrilled that he dropped; Carter should be able to start eventually once Rashean Mathis moves on.):   http://walterfootball.com/offseason2015det.php

CBS Grades (Lions get a B- for the Carter pick):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/story/25161769/grades-2015-nfl-draft-round-3

2015 Draft in Review: Detroit Lions (Round 3: Alex Carter, CB, Stanford: Grade: D, Carter is not a player we saw going anywhere near this high, particularly with so many better corners still on the board. He did earn a positive overall grade, but his coverage grade ranked 93rd out of 134 cornerbacks in the draft class. Depth Chart Fit: Expected to be a backup and special teams player early on.) (5-6-15):   https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2015/05/01/2015-draft-in-review-detroit-lions/

Grades:

A-: 1
B-: 1
D:  1

Round 4:

Walter football Grades(Detroit Lions: Gabe Wright, DT, Auburn: B+ Grade: This is another quality pick by the Lions. Gabe Wright was a solid fourth-round prospect, so they're getting him at the right spot. He also fills a need; Detroit had to add multiple defensive tackles in the wake of losing Ndamukong Suh and Nick Fairley this offseason.):   http://walterfootball.com/nfldraftgrades4.php

CBS Draft Tracker (The desire to replace two defensive tackles is clear but Grady Jarrett and Michael Bennett are still on the board. Grade: C-):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/story/25161772/grades-2015-nfl-draft-round-4 

Grades:

B+: 1
C-:  1

Round 5:

Walter football Grades (Detroit Lions: Mike Burton, FB, Rutgers: C Grade  Mike Burton is a solid pass-catcher and blocker, and he'll be able to contribute on special teams. I thought he'd go a round or two later than this, but I don't have a problem with this selection.):   http://walterfootball.com/nfldraftgrades5.php

CBS Draft Tracker (FB Michael Burton:  More of a hybrid H-back type than lead blocker. Detroit is going to have a heck of a running game next season so a fullback makes some sense.  Grade: C):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/drafttracker

Grades:

C: 2

Round 6:

CBS Grades (Quandre Diggs:  Diggs biggest detriment is his lack of size. He's a stumpy cornerback with tremendous ball skills and understanding of his position. A tough, competitive guy who can make a final 53. Grade: A-):  http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/drafttracker

Walter football Grades (Detroit Lions: Quandre Diggs, CB, Texas: B Grade  Though Quandre Diggs was projected to go in this range, this is a value choice in that he was slotted earlier prior to an awful Combine showing. Diggs showed horrible athleticism, but he could end up having the last laugh if he ends up being a solid slot corner, as once projected.):   http://walterfootball.com/nfldraftgrades6.php

Grades:

A-: 1
B: 1

Round 7:

Walter football Grades (Detroit Lions: Corey Robinson, OT, South Carolina: A+ Grade  I had the Lions picking Corey Robinson in the final version of my mock draft - at No. 88 in the third round! I thought that was a bit early for Robinson, whom I pegged as a fourth-rounder, but there was no reason for him to fall this far. At least, no reason we're aware of. We'll try to figure out why Robinson fell, but for now, this is an easy A+, as Robinson has the talent to start for the Lions at some point down the road.):   http://walterfootball.com/nfldraftgrades7.php

CBS Football Grades (Detroit has had an outstanding draft so far in large part to their offensive line additions. Robinson is enormous and can be an excellent backup player in the league with potential to spot start. Grade: B+):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/story/25161778/grades-2015-nfl-draft-round-7

Grades:

A+: 1
B+: 1

Overall:

Doug Farrar, Sports Illustrated (Detroit Lions: A-: The Lions have dealt with offensive line issues even as they've established themselves as one of the NFL's more prolific pass-heavy teams in the last few seasons. With their first two picks in the draft, they sought to bring more balance to the Force, so to speak. First-round guard Laken Tomlinson from Duke is a big, smart, aggressive player whose stock has been rising. And Nebraska back Ameer Abdullah is a great fit for Jim Caldwell's scheme as a pure one-cut-and-go runner. Third-round cornerback Alex Carter from Stanford may project better as a safety in the long run. He's a little too slow in his transitions to deal with the best outside receivers. Fourth-round defensive tackle Gabe Wright from Auburn won't make anyone forget about Ndamukong Suh, but he is a reliable rotational player with some production potential. The potential sleeper pick here is Texas cornerback Quandre Diggs, a four-year starter who's the brother of Quentin Jammer and projects pretty well as a slot corner.):   http://www.si.com/nfl/2015/05/02/2015-nfl-draft-grades-winners-losers

Fox sports Grades ( 22. Detroit Lions – A-: Detroit got a two-for-one, trading back five spots with the Denver Broncos. By allowing John Elway to take Missouri’s Shane Ray 23rd overall, the Lions picked up veteran center Manny Ramirez in a trade and selected a polished guard in Duke’s Laken Tomlinson. Detroit got a swing-for-the-fences threat in Nebraska’s Ameer Abdullah at 57th overall. Teryl Austin’s defense then scored a long, athletic cornerback in Alex Carter on Day 2. With Ndamukong Suh and Nick Fairley’s departures this offseason, the Lions added Auburn’s Gabe Wright.):   http://www.foxsports.com/nfl/lists/2015-nfl-draft-grades-dallas-cowboys-cleveland-browns-philadelphia-eagles-050215#img_10

NFL.com's Casserly's 2015 Draft Grade: Lions (he gave the Lions a B+):   http://www.nfl.com/videos/detroit-lions/0ap3000000490712/2015-Draft-Grade-Lions

Draft Grades: NFC North (Detroit Lions: The Lions entered the draft with needs on both sides of the line of scrimmage and answered the offensive side of things in round one with Laken Tomlinson. Though I was slightly surprised the Duke senior was selected in the first round he’s a big bodied blocker efficient in both pass protection and as a run blocker. I would expect him to be a starter from day one. Second round choice Ameer Abdullah is another draft pick that should get every opportunity to play as a rookie. What’s most exciting about Abdullah is he’s unlike any back on the Lions roster. Third round pick Alex Carter is another who could end up as a starter in 2015. The junior cornerback offers size, toughness and solid ball skills. He needs polish on his game but has an upside. Needs on the defensive line were finally answered in the fourth round when the team tabbed Auburn senior Gabe Wright, whose style parallels former first round pick Nick Fairley. Wright had a solid career and was very impressive during the Senior Bowl. Fullback Michael Burton was a surprise fifth round pick but could win the starting position this season by default. He’s a terrific blocker and also effective catching the ball out of the backfield but a very average athlete. Quandre Diggs was worth a roll of the dice in round six and could play in dime packages and on special teams this season. If he gets his game back on track Corey Robinson will be a steal in the seventh round. The former defensive lineman looked spectacular at left tackle as a junior in 2013 but watched his game fall off last season. He has the necessary tools to line-up as a right tackle on Sunday. Offensive lineman Al Bond, tight end Casey Pierceand safety Isaiah Johnson led an impressive class of undrafted free agents the team signed. Grade: B+ - I thought Tomlinson was a slight reach but an understandable choice. I count four potential starters from this class with a fifth waiting in the wings. Factor in two rotational players and several UDFA’s who could make the roster and this was an impressive effort by the Lions.):   http://www.draftinsider.net/blog/?p=10566

SN Draft Grades (Lions get a B: The picks: G Laken Tomlinson, RB Ameer Abdullah, CB Alex Carter, DT Gabe Wright, RB Michael Burton, CB Quandre Diggs, T Corey Robinson. The Lions slid to ‘tweener status after having their defensive line gutted in free agency, but this is a nice rebound to help their wild-card chances. They methodically filled their needs with good values for Tomlinson, Abdullah, Carter and Wright. Mission accomplished of getting stronger in the running game and deeper in the secondary.):   http://www.sportingnews.com/nfl/story/2015-05-02/nfl-draft-2015-grading-grades-team-by-team-picks-steelers-jets-patriots-seahawks-cowboys-packers-broncos

Detroit Lions draft grade roundup: Most analysts like team's solid, not spectacular selections (Mel Kiper gives the Lions a B: "Even if Tomlinson is a bit of a reach, you added one starter and potentially two with the value of a single pick. That's not too bad. "):   http://www.mlive.com/lions/index.ssf/2015/05/detroit_lions_draft_grade_roun.html

NFC North draft grades: Home-field advantage? (Detroit Lions: The Lions' draft lacked sizzle, but GM Martin Mayhew deserves credit for adding productive players to the roster throughout the draft. Guard Laken Tomlinsongives the Lions a "people mover" on the inside. He excels at driving big bodies off the line of scrimmage, creating huge lanes for runners on power runs. Ameer Abdullah is an explosive change-of-pace back with the hands and receiving skills to shine as a third-down specialist. Defensively, the Lions might have gone a long way in addressing secondary woes with the selections of cornerbacks Alex Carter and Quandre Diggs. Each defender logged significant snaps in college and brings much-needed versatility to the back end. GRADE: B):   http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000491364/article/nfc-north-draft-grades-instant-impact-from-new-bears-regime

2015 NFL Draft: Quick-snap grades for all 32 teams (Day 3 grade: C+, Overall grade: B: The skinny: In a span of about 30 minutes, the Lions upgraded their interior offensive line and managed to get more picks in the process.Matthew Stafford is no doubt quite happy at this news, and while some saw Tomlinson as a reach at the tail end of the first round, he's a safe pick that will help the team. Abdullah was Mayock's No. 3 back in the draft and is a steal at the end of the second round. He'll be a nice fit in the Lions offense while replacing Reggie Bush. Carter is a smart corner who could wind up being a nice weapon, given the other quarterbacks and wideouts in the division. Bottom line: Addressed some big needs early while moving around in the draft. Taking a chance on some players' development from the third day.):   http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000488931/article/2015-nfl-draft-quicksnap-grades-for-nfc-north-teams

Freep writers grade the Lions' 2015 draft class (Birkett gives the Lions a B, Monarrez gives the Lions a B- and Sharp gives them a C):   http://www.freep.com/story/sports/nfl/lions/2015/05/02/detroit-lions-draft-grades/26801917/

CBS' Rob Rang's Draft Grades (Detroit Lions: I anticipated that Detroit would land an interior lineman in the first round, but thought it would come on the defensive side of the ball rather than guard Laken Tomlinson. His powerful game and dependability fit in well with what Jim Caldwell is trying to build in Detroit and gives the Lions as solid a 1-2 punch at guard (with Larry Warford) as there is in the league. The defensive tackle came a little later with former Auburn standout Gabe Wright, who Lions fans hope will provide more consistency than fellow former Tiger (and Lion) Nick Fairley. The star of this class will be running back Ameer Abdullah, a verifiable star who will provide the sizzle to complement the more powerful Joique Bell and Theo Riddick. Corners Alex Carter and Quandre Diggs have talent, but never made as many plays at the collegiate level as their hype would indicate.  Grade: B-):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/nfl-draft-scout/25172622/nfc-north-draft-grades-vikings-defense-looks-ready-to-conquer

CBS' Prisco's Grades (Detroit Lions: Best Pick: I loved the pick of guard Laken Tomlinson in the first round. He gives them a great pair of guards with Larry Warford. They will be able to run the football now with those two power players. Questionable move: I like running back Ameer Abdullah, but they needed to get more of a power runner and the second round was a little high for him. He also has to cut down on his fumbling. Third-day gem: CB Quandre Diggs was a four-year starter at Texas, but he is short at 5-9. That would likely make him an ideal slot corner, but in the sixth round that is a nice pick. Analysis: Over the course of the three days, the Lions did a solid job. It's clear they want to help their run game. They also traded to get Denver center Manny Ramirez, who should start. Tomlinson isn't a sexy pick, but he is a good player. Grade: B-):   http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/writer/pete-prisco/25172342/nfl-draft-grades-jaguars-dolphins-ravens-cardinals-score-highest

SOE's Grades (23. Detroit Lions: First Pick: Laken Tomlinson, Best Pick: Ameer Abdullah. Laken Tomlinson is a very good guard prospect (probably the best in the class) and will help continue to improve the Lions offensive line and give Matt Stafford time to utilize all those great pass-catching weapons they've acquired the last few years. If Abdullah can overcome his ball security issues, he is a fantastic replacement for Reggie Bush and will be another pass-catching weapon either way. After those two picks, things were a little less exciting. The Lions seemed to try and get upside, but that means they could end up with a lot of just average guys if they don't pan out. Grade: B-):   http://www.sportsonearth.com/article/122221416/nfl-draft-grades-bucs-titans-jaguars-raiders-jets

Evan Silva, RotoWorld (Overview: GM Martin Mayhew began his draft by acquiring two fifth-round picks and useful reserve G/C Manuel Ramirez from the Broncos at the cost of dropping just five spots in round one. The Lions were surprisingly hot after CB/S tweener Carter on day two, sending the 143rd pick to division-rival Minnesota in exchange for just an eight-spot move up the board. Early on day three, the Lions gave up a 2016 third-round pick for No. 113. Tomlinson may not have offered ideal "value" at No. 28, but is a pro-ready mauler with underrated pass-blocking ability. Abdullah will run circles around Joique Bell in Lions camp and spark Detroit's previously plodding run game. Carter, Wright, and Burton are players I wasn't especially high on during the pre-draft phase. I do think Robinson was an excellent flier. Although this wasn't my favorite draft from top to bottom, Mayhew attacked multiple needs and made his team better. Lions Grade: C+):   http://www.rotoworld.com/articles/nfl/53887/174/draft-2015-nfc-draft-grades

Shutdown Corner's Grade (Lions grade is a C+):   http://sports.yahoo.com/photos/shutdown-corner-breaks-down-the-nfl-draft-picks-by-team-photo-1430719159025.html

TSN's Grade (Detroit Lions: Laken Tomlinson (OG, Duke) Round 1 (28); Ameer Abdullah (RB, Nebraska) Round 2 (54); Alex Carter (CB, Stanford) Round 3 (80); Gabe Wright (DT, Auburn) Round 4 (113); Michael Burton (FB, Rutgers) Round 5 (168); Quandre Diggs (CB, Texas) Round 6 (200); Corey Robinson (OT, South Carolina) Round 7 (240) - Lions GM Martin Mayhew struggled early before steadying himself a bit. Tomlinson may end up being a really good guard in this league because he can beat people up in the phone booth, but taking the Duke product at No. 28 overall defines reach. Abdullah, meanwhile, is spectacular in the open field, but he's a gimmick player at this level because he doesn't block well enough to be a third-down back and he doesn't have the frame or ball security to handle it 20 times a game. Carter is versatile and could project on the inside of the defensive backfield at free safety or stay on the outside.  Best Value: The Lions lost both Ndamukong Suh and Nick Fairley in free agency while adding Haloti Ngata and Tyrunn Walker. That's not a great trade-off and more help was needed. Enter Wright, who has the first step to be a handful in a 1-gap defense.  Questionable Call: Much like the Travis Frederick pick for Dallas in 2013, the Tomlinson selection might look good in a few years for the Lions, but that fails to understand what the draft is about. Detroit could have had Tomlinson much later, so if that's who Mayhew wanted, trade out and pick up another asset. Grade: There just wasn't enough value at the top of this draft board to be impressed. C+):   http://www.sportsnetwork.com/merge/tsnform.aspx?c=sportsnetwork&page=nfl/writers/extrapoints/archive/extrapoints_050415.htm

Grades:

A-: 2
B+: 2
B: 5
B-: 4
C+: 4
C: 1

Trade Grades:

2015 NFL Draft Trade Grades (Lions get a B+, Broncos get a B+:  Lions trade No. 23 to Broncos for No. 28, 143 (5th), 2016 5th-rounder, Manny Ramirez - This seems like a lot to move up just five spots in the 20s, but unlike the Chargers, I can understand why the Broncos did it. There were just too many teams that could've taken Shane Ray - Arizona, Baltimore, Dallas - before the 28th-overall selection. Ray was a steal; he was once a projected top-10 selection, but character issues made him fall. The Broncos are desperate to win now, so it's understandable why they would not only take a risk, but move a lineman and two fifth-rounders just to get a talented prospect. The Lions, meanwhile, had their eye on improving the offensive line. They added Manny Ramirez via this trade and Laken Tomlinson five spots later. Tomlinson was still a slight reach at that point, but I like that Detroit moved down rather than take their guy extremely prematurely. I feel like both teams won this trade. It made sense to each franchise, and both the Lions and Broncos figure to benefit.):   http://walterfootball.com/draft2015tradegrades.php

No comments:

Post a Comment

.main-inner .sidebar .Poll { background-color: #AD966C; padding: 15px; }